Super.so is great for public Notion sites, but doesn't have login functionality. NotionMember is built specifically for members-only content with authentication baked in.
Super.so excels at creating beautiful public Notion websites. But when you need to protect content behind a login wall, things get complicated.
Super.so doesn't have native login functionality. You need third-party tools like Memberstack or Outseta.
Setting up authentication requires connecting multiple services and writing custom code.
Third-party auth tools add $29-$99+/month on top of your Super.so subscription.
Managing multiple integrations means more things that can break and need fixing.
Unlike Super.so, NotionMember was built from the ground up for members-only Notion content. Authentication isn't an afterthought—it's the core feature.
Native authentication without third-party integrations. Just add member emails.
Simple dashboard to add, remove, and manage member access.
Passwordless sign-in. Members get magic links via email.
Update in Notion, changes appear immediately. No republishing.
Use your own domain for a branded experience.
One tool, one price. No stacking multiple services.
Side-by-side comparison for member site functionality
Super.so is excellent for public Notion websites. NotionMember is better for members-only content.
"I tried setting up Super.so with Memberstack but the integration was a nightmare. Switched to NotionMember and had my member site running in 10 minutes."
— Course creator who switched from Super.so
Super.so doesn't have built-in login functionality. You'd need to integrate third-party tools like Memberstack, Outseta, or MemberSpace, which adds complexity and cost. NotionMember has authentication built-in.
NotionMember focuses on member functionality rather than extensive design customization. If you need a highly customized public website, Super.so might be better. For member sites, NotionMember provides everything you need.
Yes! Since both tools connect to Notion, you can easily switch. Just connect your Notion workspace to NotionMember, add your members, and you're ready to go.
You can use Super.so for your public website and NotionMember for your members-only pages. Many users use both tools for different purposes.
Stop wrestling with auth integrations. Get member login that just works.
Free plan available • No credit card required